Thursday, May 29, 2008

Does Not Compute

Far be it from me to criticize Fire Joe Morgan, quite possibly the best web site out there on the subject of firing Joe Morgan. But I do have to take slight exception with one of their arguments in a recent post about instant replay. The FJM guys are in favor of the introduction of instant replay in baseball, which is good, because the people opposing it tend to rely on the same flimsy "preserve the sanctity of the game, you can't change the way it's always been" arguments that could just as easily have been used to oppose, say, having black people on your team. And since Ken Griffey Jr. is my all-time favorite player, I tend not to like those arguments.

So, Mose Schrute & Co. seem to be on the right side of things, except a little farther down in their post, they say this:

"If this plan were to take QuesTec and create a LASERTechnoGrid™ on every batter and put a chip in the ball and have the LASERTechnoGrid™ turn red for strikes and green for balls, then yes, I would say, that's silly, and let's let humans be humans. But huge game-altering HR calls? That can be corrected with like a minute's review of normal TV camera work? Why not do that?"

See, right now, instant reply is being proposed only for use in home run calls, and FJM is in favor of that. But when it comes to balls and strikes and other more mundane determinations, they come down in favor of human umpires. And while I could spend years arguing against people who are against replay altogether, it seems more fun to take on this more nuanced position.

At the risk of offending the all-powerful Umpires Union of America (not to mention the guys at FJM, who I probably respect much more than I should considering I have never and will never meet them), I don't see why we can't computerize whatever the hell we want. Sure, a blown home run call is much more likely to affect the course of a season than a blown strike call, but why risk blowing any calls now that a computer can just tell us what's a strike and what's not? Robotic umpires may seem scary, but I think we have to get over that. Shoeless Joe Jackson said he didn't like the stadium lights in Field of Dreams, but we installed the damn things anyway, so we could have Red Sox-Yankees games that go until 1 AM and slowly drive us insane. The system works.

Is it that we don't want certainty? Do we not want to pin the strike zone down? The strike zone is famously fickle, expanding for marquee pitchers, no-hitters, etc. I can see the legitimacy in the argument that we're better off keeping that rather charming element of baseball. But I disagree with that--I don't want to gawk at a pitcher's stats or enjoy a no-hitter unless I know for sure all the calls are legit. Sometimes, when I watch the replay of the last out of Clay Buchholz's no-hitter, I think that curveball might just have been half an inch off the plate. If I knew for sure, I'd be able to celebrate in peace. And if the last game of the World Series did come down to a questionable strike call, I think the last thing I'd want to do is let humans be humans.

No comments: